OK I am completely confused about the status of "replies" in…

From Blygger

OK I am completely confused about the status of "replies" in #Blygger. The 0.3 spec says both "a stub is a response" and "a stub is not a reply". I don't understand the difference. And if its too obscure for me to grasp it probably needs to get clarified if this is going to be a widely-shared protocol. blygger-spec/docs/protocol-v0.3.md at main · blygger/blygger-spec · GitHub

will blyg about this in hopes of a response if not a reply haha.
I suppose this is an aspect of the design principle "this is a network of soapboxes, not a conversational medium". I not only don't like this rule, I think it's incoherent, as the confusing language indicates. Are you trying to technically legislate non-arguments? I suppose a lot of that kind of thing is tedious and boring, especially when it is across ideological lines, but calling it something else probably isn't going to help.

But I like to argue and I like to be argued back at. Is that obnoxious? I don't know, I find soapbox-types pretty obnoxious and I have no desire to be one (so one of my dreams has succeded) ou get good arguments when you have a good set of people who agree on some fundamental values and disagree on others.

Oh actually I just figured out the difference (I think): "reply" denotes a kind of 1st-person style of direct argument, where person A and B are talking back to each other. "response", or citation, implies that you are talking to a 3rd party about a 2nd party. A is talking about B to C, where C is the audience. Isn't there a senate rule about that?
  • Ask Claude
    • Yes, you've hit on exactly the right analogy. Under Senate Rule XIX:
    • All speeches must be addressed to the Presiding Officer. Only the Presiding Officer may be directly addressed in speeches; other members must be referred to in the third person.
    • In most cases, senators refer to each other not by name, but by state, using forms such as "the senior senator from Virginia" or "the junior senator from California."
    • So the structural logic is identical to your reply/response distinction: a Senator never directly addresses a colleague on the floor — they speak to the Chair about the colleague. Senator A addresses the Presiding Officer (C) about Senator B. Direct second-person address between senators isn't the form debate takes...
    • That seems like a crisp way to clarify the spec. The distinction is real and meaningful — it might just need a sentence in the docs that makes the rhetorical direction explicit, perhaps something like: "a stub is addressed to readers, not to the author of the cited post."
Hm maybe, I think it needs better naming or it will cause a lot of confusion. Why not "citation" as the primitive if that is what they are? It was explained to me as like quoting a tweet, so maybe call it a quotation?

Created Sep 29, 2026 · updated Nov 20, 2026 · v8

JSON · Blyg