AMMDI Blyg

This post is about political strategy – how Democrats can win by being more fun, eg throwing more weenie roasts and block parties. But it touches on deeper issues of human motivation. Why do people participate in politics? It could be from a deep sense of justice or idealism or a vision of a better future – there are people like that – but mostly it's because its fun, its an activity that gets you out of the house to be with people, maybe a chance to dress up in a costume. Doing political work for the sake of some future goal is work, but play is a better motivator (see WorkPlay )
like Milwaukee’s sewer socialists, Mr. Mamdani’s organization spent years building a movement through community events. The New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America (of which I’m a member) offers daily opportunities for face-to-face socializing: a “Sing in Solidarity” choir, soccer and softball leagues, picnics and potlucks, “Coffee with Comrades,” a running club, dance parties, singles mixers, game nights and birding outings.
One of the appeals of Trump is that for a lot of people, he coded fun and Democrats coded as scoldy, old, and too serious.
  • This is a really important point. For the most part Democrats didn't understand this, because Trump's insult-comic pro-wrestling side was too lowbrow and nasty to seem like fun to them, but it's obvious in retrospect that that was a huge part of what was going on.
In Homo Ludens terms, there is an important play-element in politics:
  • Ask Claude
    • Here is an expansion of the Homo Ludens angle for your outline item:

    • The Play-Element in Politics: A Homo Ludens Expansion

    • Huizinga's Core Claim

    • In Homo Ludens, Johan Huizinga defines play as the central activity in flourishing societies.
    • His thesis is not that play is a frivolous add-on to serious life — it's the reverse: civilization arises and unfolds "in and as play."
    • Crucially, war, religion, politics, sports, and even the arts contain elements of play that drive their production.
    • Huizinga saw this clearly in American electoral life specifically. With an eye for his own times he wrote: "In American politics [play] is even more evident. Long before the two-party system had reduced itself to two gigantic teams whose political differences were hardly discernible to an outsider, electioneering in America had developed into a kind of national sport."

    • What Play Actually Is (The Five Characteristics)

    • Huizinga identifies five characteristics of play: it is free; it is not "ordinary" or "real" life; it is distinct from "ordinary" life both as to locality and duration; it creates order; it is connected with no material interest, and from it no profit can be gained. Each of these maps onto the experience of political participation as described in the LGM post:
    • Freedom/Voluntariness:
    • First and foremost, all play is a voluntary activity. Play to order is no longer play.
    • Nobody has to attend a DSA picnic or a "Coffee with Comrades" — the draw is intrinsic, not obligatory.
    • Separation from ordinary life:
    • The playful demands that the player separate himself from real life and enter a temporary sphere of activity with its own dispositions and rules.
    • The rally, the march, the block party — these are all set apart from the weekday grind.
    • The Magic Circle:
    • The consciousness of play as a separate and self-contained sphere is often reinforced by the pervasive tendency to enclose the players within a spatiotemporal frame, the so-called "magic circle," which isolates their game from the more serious tasks of daily living.
    • The parade route, the union hall, the picnic ground — these are literal magic circles where different norms apply. Inside the circle, nothing is trivial, because everything has been voluntarily elevated to significance by the collective agreement to play.
    • Costume and disguise:
    • Play is a free activity standing quite consciously outside "ordinary" life as being "not serious," but at the same time absorbing the player intensely and utterly. It promotes the formation of social groupings which tend to surround themselves with secrecy and to stress their difference from the common world by disguise or other means.
    • This directly explains the instinct for political costume — the matching shirts, the banners, the regalia. Even in legal contexts, Huizinga notes the peculiar use of costume or regalia in the legal profession as an expression of the same play-element.

    • The Play-Community: Where the Real Political Power Lives

    • The most important concept for understanding the sewer socialists and the DSA choir/softball/birding-club model is Huizinga's play-community.
    • According to Huizinga, play is characterized by the formation of a "play-community." This community tends to "stress their difference from the common world by disguise or other means."
    • Crucially, this community outlasts any single play event: play creates community which outlasts the actual time and field of play. A play-community generally tends to become permanent even after the game is over.
    • And what holds the community together is a distinctive feeling: the feeling of being "apart together" in an exceptional situation "retains its magic beyond the duration of the individual game."
    • This is precisely what the sewer socialists built.
    • Before sweeping into City Hall, socialists took the helm of the city's labor movement and rooted their party in Milwaukee's choirs, gymnastics clubs, and mutual-aid societies.
    • A huge part of the reason for their success lies in the culture — they built this culture of socializing and community and purpose. It was almost like a church at its best, where you have the music, you have the community.
    • In Huizingian terms: they built a durable play-community first, and political power followed.

    • The Agon: Competition as the Engine

    • Huizinga devoted much of Homo Ludens to the agon — the competitive impulse — because he saw it as the form in which the play-element did its most visible cultural work.
    • Politics is fundamentally agonistic — it is a contest. But Huizinga's point is that the contest must be conducted as play — with shared rules, mutual recognition, and a spirit of fellowship — for it to be culturally generative rather than destructive.
    • The spirit of fellowship would allow the bitterest opponents a friendly chat even after the most virulent debate. It was in this style that the "Gentleman's Agreement" arose. There can be no doubt that it is just this play-element that keeps parliamentary life healthy, at least in Great Britain.
    • The inverse is Huizinga's warning: when the once playful spheres of democratic politics, war, and international relations morph into pure seriousness, barbarism and naked cruelty follow as natural consequences.
    • Over-serious politics — politics stripped of the play-element — becomes totalitarian or merely tribal.
    • In apparently serious activities like politics hid an element of play (political games), while true play was being taken too seriously and had become technically overorganized.

    • The Synthesis

    • The LGM post's argument — throw more weenie roasts — is, in Huizingian terms, an argument for rebuilding the play-community as the substrate of political power. The DSA's choir and running club aren't decorative; they are the magic circle where the play-community forms and coheres.
    • Reading Huizinga reveals the importance of a consideration of the social relations and material conditions that shape the playful features of democratic contestation.
    • You cannot manufacture the play-spirit through top-down messaging ("joy" as a campaign aesthetic); it has to be generated from the bottom up, through actual shared play.
    • According to Huizinga, whereas religion, science, law, war, and politics gradually lose the play element over time — even politics should be play, a fair play, following certain rules, trust, and therefore culture, where there always is a play element.

Created Nov 15, 2026 · updated Nov 15, 2026 · v2

JSON · Blyg